The Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has filed an application in the Supreme Court containing its views on various recommendations made by the court-appointed Expert Committee in connection with the Adani-Hindenburg case.
In its application, the market regulator has sought "appropriate orders" from the apex court when the latter hears the case on Tuesday.
For effective enforcement policy, the expert committee, in its report, recommended, inter-alia, to develop a proper enforcement policy that would optimise the utilisation of precious regulatory resources and to lay down criteria on the basis of which the SEBI may choose what proceedings/measures to initiate.
In response, the SEBI submitted before the court that it "has a documented Enforcement Manual which is applicable to all quasi-judicial and other enforcement proceedings conducted by the SEBI, pursuant to completion of investigation or inspections or intermediaries or other examinations”.
“The enforcement manual, inter-alia, prescribes objective criteria/numerical thresholds, wherever possible, for initiation of suitable enforcement actions or administrative/soft actions for various types of securities market violations,” it added.
Responding to the Expert Committee’s observation that the proceedings initiated by the SEBI in 2021-22 have “skyrocketed”, it said that the increase was due to the large number of adjudication proceedings in Illiquid Stock Options (ISO) matters.
With regard to the judicial discipline, the SEBI said that In the ordinary course, the ratio laid down by one adjudicating officer(AO)/whole time member (WTM) are followed by another WTMs/AO, except in the cases where the latter authority does not agree with the ratio laid down by the former as it has no precedential value.
“Violations of securities laws demand prompt action so as to limit the negative impact on the securities market. The entire matrix of securities law is crafted with the objective of ensuring a secure investment environment and hence, immediate action is warranted under securities law,” it said.
It stated that in SEBI cases, if appropriate action is not taken in a timely manner, irreparable damage to investors can be caused, which cannot be reversed by the higher court.
On a robust settlement policy, the SEBI said that it already has a SEBI (Settlement Proceedings) Regulations, 2018 dealing with the procedure/process of settling a particular case and also contain provisions relating to grounds for rejection of settlement applications and calculation of settlement amount.
The SEBI opposed prescribing timelines for initiation of investigation and proceedings and said that “prescribing specific timelines to complete the investigation may compromise the quality of investigation”.
Notably, all the offences under the SEBI Act (except offence under section 11C (6), SCRA Act and Depositories Act), the SEBI can initiate prosecution without any period of limitation.
In response to the recommendation that human discretion in surveillance actions should be done away, the SEBI said that “inclusion of stocks into F&O is completely data driven, based on objective criteria, market matrix and action taken report of the entity” and “over 90 per cent of the filings on Exchanges are in machine readable form.”
On the other hand, advocate Vishal Tiwari, the PIL petitioner-in-person, in his application has argued that the court appointed committee has not given a “clearcut finding”.
“The report submitted by the Committee cannot be said to be a conclusive and final Report in respect to the Remits,” he said.
The apex court on March 2 had formed an expert committee headed by Justice A.M. Sapre, former judge of the Supreme Court with an objective to review and strengthen the existing financial regulatory mechanisms.
The top court had said: "The remit of the committee shall be as follows: To provide an overall assessment of the situation, including the relevant causal factors which have led to the volatility in the securities market in the recent past; To suggest measures to strengthen investor awareness."
It added: "To investigate whether there has been regulatory failure in dealing with the alleged contravention of laws pertaining to the securities market in relation to the Adani Group or other companies; and To suggest measures to (i) strengthen the statutory and/or regulatory framework; and (ii) secure compliance with the existing framework for the protection of investors".
The Hindenburg Research's report about Indian billionaire Gautam Adani had led to a stock rout, erasing over $ 100 billion from his empire and pushing him down on the global rich list.
The controversial report, inter alia, alleged that the Adani Group of companies has manipulated its share prices; failed to disclose transactions with related parties and other relevant information concerning related parties in contravention of the regulations framed by SEBI; and violated other provisions of securities laws.
SC to hear on Monday suo moto RG Kar doctor rape-murder case
The Supreme Court is slated to hear on Monday the matter where it has taken suo moto cognisance of the rape and murder of a junior doctor at the state-run R.G. Kar Medical College and Hospital in Kolkata.
India to co-chair key international counter-terrorism meet for first time
India is set to play a pivotal role in an upcoming international counter-terrorism meeting, marking a significant milestone in its efforts to combat terrorism globally.
No mercy for drug cartels: HM Shah on busting of international racket in northeast
An international drug racket was busted by the Narcotics Control Bureau in Guwahati and Imphal, said Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Sunday, saying that there was no mercy for drug cartels.
AR Rahman discharged from Chennai hospital, suffered dehydration symptoms
Renowned music director and double Oscar award winner A.R. Rahman, who was admitted to a private hospital in Chennai on Sunday morning, was discharged after brief hospitalisation.
New Zealand PM, accompanied by Indian diaspora members, to arrive in Delhi today
New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is set to arrive in Delhi on Sunday for an official visit to India at the invitation of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Telangana tunnel tragedy: Search for missing persons enters 23rd day
The operation to trace the remaining seven persons trapped under debris in the Srisailam Left Bank Canal (SLBC) tunnel in Telangana's Nagakurnool district entered the 23rd day on Sunday.
Official accommodation for ministers in Chandigarh being used for AAP activities, claims Cong MLA
Congress legislator and ex-AAP leader Sukhpal Singh Khaira on Sunday urged the Election Commission of India (ECI) and the Central government to take cognizance of gross misuse of official accommodation in Chandigarh meant for ministers of the Punjab government being used as Aam Aadmi Party office for political activities.
Two hawala operators held in Punjab, Rs 17,60,000 cash linked to drug trafficking seized
In a major crackdown on drug networks, Amritsar Rural Police apprehended two hawala operators -- Sukhjit Singh and Ranbir Singh, who were facilitating illegal financial transactions linked to drug trafficking with seizure of Rs 17,60,000 cash and $4,000, Punjab Director General of Police Gaurav Yadav said on Sunday.