The current rules governing the Swiss Challenge process are lopsided, favouring the anchor bidder, and stymie the basic objective of value maximisation by the lenders of a stressed asset.
This is the opinion of various banking and industry experts closely involved and associated with the Swiss Challenge process.
Highlighting the flaws in the current regulations, an analyst on the condition of anonymity said, in the extant regulations, governed by the Master Direction - Reserve Bank of India (Transfer of Loan Exposures) Directions, 2021, an anchor bidder is accorded unlimited rights, including the Right of First Refusal (ROFR), to match any potential challenger bid in the Swiss Challenge process.
This is a sort of guarantee to the Anchor Bidder to emerge the final winner in the Swiss Challenge process, even much before the process is initiated.
This restricts participation from the serious potential bidders in the Swiss Challenge process, as they know that the anchor bidder, with unlimited ROFR, will match their bid, thereby defeating the basic objective of value maximisation for conducting the challenge mechanism.
The analyst said that this is the main reason that various Swiss Challenge processes conducted by the banks in the past have failed to attract any competitive bids from the potential bidders, forcing them to accept the anchor bids as the winning bids, thereby taking a huge hair-cut on their outstanding debt in the stressed assets.
"This clause needs modification for the lenders to achieve the value maximisation through the Swiss Challenge process. The best way to encourage maximum participation from the potential bidders is by specifying the mark up in the challenge mechanism in advance," said the analyst.
Elaborating further on this, he said the anchor bidder should be allowed to match a challenger bid if that bid is 10 higher than his anchor bid. In case the difference is more than 10 per cent, then the highest challenge bid should become the winning bid.
Echoing the same sentiments, another banker said that lenders have successfully executed this formula in the Swiss Challe The current rules governing the Swiss Challenge process are lopsided, favouring the anchor bidder, and stymie the basic objective of value maximisation by the lenders of a stressed asset.
nge Process followed for the award of Jewar International Airport. In the process, Delhi International Airport Ltd (DIAL) -- the anchor bidder, had Right of First Refusal, but within a limit of 10 per cent of the highest challenger bid. This limited right of first refusal encouraged other bidders to participate in the Challenge Mechanism process, with Zurich Airport International, AG emerging as the winner.
Another analyst also suggested that the anchor bidder should also be made to submit 25 per cent of the base bid amount as upfront payment along with the base bid.
Also, the lenders should bring in more transparency in the Swiss Challenge process by publicly disclosing the essential elements of the base bid to all the bidders.
Tripura CM Dr Manik Saha to lead high-level task force for investment promotion in NE India
In a significant development of the Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s dream of making India – Viksit Bharat by 2047, the Ministry of Development of North East Region (MDoNER) has appointed Tripura Chief Minister Dr Manik Saha as the Convenor of the High-Level Task Force for investment promotion in North East region of the country.
In a first, 9 Tripura youths get nursing caregiver jobs in Japan
For the first time, nine youths from Tripura have got jobs in Japan as nursing caregivers and 60 more candidates would go to the East Asian country in the next financial year (2025-26) for work, officials said here on Saturday.
108-year-old Tripura Palace to turn into 5-star hotel; deal signed amid protests by allies, Oppn
Despite vehement protests by the ruling BJP's ally Tipra Motha Party (TMP) and the Opposition, the Tripura government on Friday signed an agreement with the Indian Hotels Company Ltd. (IHCL) to make the 108-year-old Pushpabanta Palace in Agartala a 5-star hotel.
Tripura CM tells police, lawyers to increase conviction rate
Tripura Chief Minister Manik Saha on Friday asked the top police officers, law enforcement agencies, lawyers, and other stakeholders to take all steps to increase the conviction rates.
Govt working to develop Bankul as most attractive tourist spot in Tripura: CM Dr Manik Saha
Chief Minister Dr Manik Saha on Thursday inaugurated the 78th Bankul Mahamuni festival of the Buddhists community in the Buddha temple at Sabroom Manubankul and said that the government has taken initiative to develop Bankul as one of the most attractive tourist spots of the state.
PM Modi led Govt given special importance to socio-economic development and self-empowerment of women: CM Dr Manik Saha
Chief Minister Dr Manik Saha on Thursday inaugurated the state level celebration of the International Women’s Day here at Agartala Rabindra Satabarshiki Bhavan and said that the government has given special importance to the socio-economic development and self-empowerment of women of the country.
THRC seeks report from DGP over FIR refusal
The Tripura Human Rights Commission (THRC) has directed Director General of Police (DGP) Amitabh Ranjan to investigate allegations that police personnel in North Tripura refused to register an FIR and to submit a report by April 24.
Outrage over puppy killing video, Minister orders arrest
A harrowing case of animal cruelty in Tripura’s Khowai district has triggered widespread outrage after a disturbing video of a youth brutally killing a puppy surfaced on social media.