The Delhi High Court has given a final chance to the Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India and the National Restaurant Association of India to file their affidavits, as per the order issued on April 12 regarding levy of service charge by their members.
However, this chance comes with a condition that they must each pay a penalty of Rs. 1 lakh.
Both associations have failed to comply with the previous order, leading to complete non-compliance, and Justice Prathiba M. Singh has granted them a final opportunity to submit the required affidavits within four days.
Justice Singh said that the penalty amount should be paid to the Pay and Accounts Office, Department of Consumer Affairs, New Delhi, via a demand draft.
The court further said that only upon the payment of the penalty will their affidavits be considered and accepted by the court. Failure to deposit the penalty will result in the affidavits not being taken into account.
On April 12, the high court had said that its interim order staying the guidelines of Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA), that prohibit the hotels and restaurants from levying service charges "automatically or by default" on bills, shall not be shown on the menu cards or display boards in a manner to mislead the consumers that the service charge has been approved by the court.
The Federation of Hotels and Restaurant Associations of India and National Restaurant Association of India had challenged the CCPA's rules released on July 4 last year, which the high court stayed later that month.
A co-ordinate bench had stayed the guidelines, while specifying that the service charge and obligation of the customer to pay it must be "duly and prominently displayed on the menu or other places".
"It is clarified that the interim order shall not be shown in the display board or menu card in a manner to mislead the consumer that the service charge has been approved by this court," Justice Singh had said.
Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma had submitted that various restaurants are "misinterpreting the interim order" by using it to give legitimacy to levy of the service charge.
Both Associations were ordered by Justice Singh to produce an affidavit stating the proportion of their members who are requiring the service charge as a requirement on meal bills.
The court had further stated that the response must state whether the members would object if the term "service charge" were to be replaced with another term, such as "staff welfare fund, staff welfare contribution, or staff charges", in order to prevent consumers from assuming that the fee is being levied by the government.
"The affidavit shall also indicate the percentage of members who are willing to inform the consumers that the service charge is not mandatory and they can contribute voluntarily," the court had said.
"For a long time, most of us thought that the service charge is being taken by the government. That is where the problem is because people think service charge is like a service tax. A consumer doesn’t know the difference between service tax, GST etc. because people think it is being taken by the government. I have come across a lot of people who think like that," the court had said.
The Centre had earlier argued that the recommendations were released in the best interests of consumers and urged the court to take the matter into consideration, including its plea for the vacation of the stay order.
It had apprised the court that certain restaurants were currently relying on the interim order to create the image that they are permitted to impose service charges.
Justice Singh had said that without hearing the parties, the interim order cannot be modified and added that the application for a vacation of stay shall be taken into consideration if the main case cannot be heard on the next date.
Counsel appearing for the petitioners had said the service charge, which has been in existence for the last several years, is a "traditional charge" and is distributed among those who "are not before the customers", and restaurants are seeking it after displaying due notice of the same on their menu cards and in their premises. The petitioners had further claimed that the CCPA's order is arbitrary, untenable and ought to be quashed.
Landed in India, a country of huge importance: New Zealand PM
New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon received a warm welcome from Union Minister of State S.P. Singh Baghel as he arrived in Delhi for his first official visit to India.
Suicide blast in Balochistan: 5 Pakistani soldiers killed, claims Baloch Liberation Army
At least five Pakistani soldiers were killed and more than ten injured after a deadly explosion rocked the Pakistani Army convoy in Balochistan’s Noshki, reports said.
SC to hear on Monday suo moto RG Kar doctor rape-murder case
The Supreme Court is slated to hear on Monday the matter where it has taken suo moto cognisance of the rape and murder of a junior doctor at the state-run R.G. Kar Medical College and Hospital in Kolkata.
India to co-chair key international counter-terrorism meet for first time
India is set to play a pivotal role in an upcoming international counter-terrorism meeting, marking a significant milestone in its efforts to combat terrorism globally.
No mercy for drug cartels: HM Shah on busting of international racket in northeast
An international drug racket was busted by the Narcotics Control Bureau in Guwahati and Imphal, said Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Sunday, saying that there was no mercy for drug cartels.
AR Rahman discharged from Chennai hospital, suffered dehydration symptoms
Renowned music director and double Oscar award winner A.R. Rahman, who was admitted to a private hospital in Chennai on Sunday morning, was discharged after brief hospitalisation.
New Zealand PM, accompanied by Indian diaspora members, to arrive in Delhi today
New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon is set to arrive in Delhi on Sunday for an official visit to India at the invitation of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Telangana tunnel tragedy: Search for missing persons enters 23rd day
The operation to trace the remaining seven persons trapped under debris in the Srisailam Left Bank Canal (SLBC) tunnel in Telangana's Nagakurnool district entered the 23rd day on Sunday.